Skip to content

Jean-Benoit Buisson

Every page on PoolsideVerdict is written and signed by one named person. This page explains where the judgments come from, lists what the author is not, and gives an address for corrections.

How this began

It started with a flow rate. A pump box says 2,500 GPH, and nearly every listing treats that as what the pool gets. It is not: the figure is measured with no filter, no hose and no lift. Intex is one of the few makers that prints both numbers, and its 2,500 GPH pump delivers 1,900 GPH to the pool. Once that gap is visible, the same shape turns up across the whole shelf. Pools sold on gallons stated at 90% fill, or at no stated level at all. Heat pumps sold on a COP without the air it was measured in. Liners sold by gauge, which converts to nothing.

The second problem arrives after the box is open. This equipment is bought on a headline and kept or returned on details: a pump cut for 1-1/4 in hose on a pool plumbed for 1-1/2 in, a cartridge type the local store does not stock, a salt system that needs a set ppm of salt before it makes any chlorine, a heat pump that wants a 240 V circuit the yard does not have. None of that is on the front of the box.

So the site does the dull part. Each product page is written from its Amazon.com listing, read for a US address, with the maker’s documents where they exist. It writes down the line that settles the question, keeps each figure with its conditions, converts metric figures where a listing gives only metric, and says plainly when a figure was not published or when a listing contradicts itself.

The whole catalog, built by the compiler

Nobody maintains the list below by hand. It is regenerated from the catalog on every compile, one line per published page, and it grows or shrinks on its own as a shelf opens or a reference disappears. It records what has been written up.

Three lessons from this shelf

The figure in the biggest type is rarely the one the purchase hangs on. A pump is sold on GPH when the hose size decides whether it connects. A pool is sold on its diameter when its gallons decide every chemical dose. A robot is sold on runtime when the surfaces it climbs decide what that runtime is spent on.

What it costs to keep going outlives what it cost to bring home. A filter takes one cartridge type for its whole life, and that choice sets the cost of every season after. A salt cell is a wear part. A liner that came with the pool is replaced by size and bead type, not by brand.

The thing you finally judge it on is often nowhere on the listing: how loud a pump is at seven in the morning, whether a ladder wobbles on a sloped yard, whether the part that goes first is still sold the day it goes. Amazon buyer ratings catch some of that, which is why each page carries a score built from them.

What I am not

I am not a pool installer, a water chemist, an electrician or a certification body. I hold no qualification in those fields and I have never worked for a manufacturer, an importer or a dealer. Each page describes what the listing and the maker state, what Amazon buyers rate it, and where those sources disagree. Nothing here is described as cleaner, quieter or safer than anything else on the strength of a listing.

This site is not an installation manual and not water-treatment advice. For a pump’s electrical protection, a heater’s circuit, a chemical’s dose and what it must never be mixed with, it points to the maker’s instructions, the product label and safety data sheet, local codes and NEC Article 680. No ladder, light, cover or chlorinator is described here as making anything safe.

A name at the bottom proves nothing on its own. Each judgment carries its grounds inside the page that makes it, and the long version, how we judge and rank, has a page of its own.

The five rules a page is built under

  • No figure gets in without its source: the listing, the maker’s manual or data sheet, a named standard, or Amazon buyer ratings.
  • Nothing is filled in to look complete. Where nobody published a figure, the page says it was not published.
  • Every product is checked on Amazon.com for a US address before the page goes up. Products without a US listing are not covered.
  • Where the cheaper option is the right one, the page says so, and where the right answer is leveling the ground or testing the water before buying anything, it says that instead.
  • When a listing contradicts itself, the page names both figures and the one it used.

The price of misreading a figure

On this shelf the gap between what a number states and what it is read as usually shows up once the pool is full. Stated gallons stand in for the water a pool holds. Flow with nothing attached stands in for turnover. Meanwhile the things treated as afterthoughts, a ground cloth, a spare cartridge, a cover pulled over at dusk, a test before a dose, decide whether any of it worked. Much of that costs nothing to know, and this site says so even where it earns nothing.

Sending a correction

Point out a mistake and it is put right, with the date of the correction left on the page for anyone to see. Write to [email protected].

Jean-Benoit Buisson · PoolsideVerdict · Paris, France