Skip to content

How we judge and rank

Every page on this site is written from the Amazon.com listing of the product it describes, read for a US delivery address. This page says what is read, how the score is calculated, which figures are converted and what the site will not claim.

What we read, and for which address

Each product page starts from one Amazon.com listing, opened for a delivery address in New York. We record the title, the bullet points, the specification table, the star rating with its number of ratings, and the price shown that day. Where the maker publishes a manual or a data sheet, it outranks the listing on anything structural: hose sizes, cartridge types, thread sizes, bead types.

A product without an Amazon.com listing does not get a page. Equipment built for 230 V European supply, or sold only on European Amazon stores, was removed from the catalog on November 2, 2026.

First question: will it fit what you have

Before price, a page asks whether the product works with the pool and the supply already in your yard. A frame-pool pump uses 1-1/4 or 1-1/2 in hoses. A cartridge is an Intex Type A or B, a Bestway Type I or IV, or a tank element named by part number. A liner is overlap, beaded or unibead. A heat pump or heater needs a 120 V or 240 V circuit. Where the listing does not say, the page records that it does not say.

Where the score comes from

The score out of 10 on each product page is calculated from Amazon.com buyer ratings. We take the average star rating and its number of ratings, pull the average toward 4.3 stars with the weight of 20 ratings, and scale the result to 10. A product rated 4.8 by three buyers therefore scores below one rated 4.6 by three thousand.

It is a measure of buyer satisfaction. It does not know whether the buyers sized their pump correctly, and it says nothing about a product too new to have ratings. The order of a family page follows its stated criteria, such as price, capacity or fit, and the score is one input among them.

A figure keeps its conditions

A pump’s GPH is the flow with nothing attached; where the maker gives the flow that reaches the pool, both appear, as with Intex’s 2,500 GPH pump rated 1,900 GPH in the pool. A heat pump’s COP keeps the standard or temperatures it was measured at. A pool’s stated gallons are checked against its own dimensions, and a figure that cannot be right is named.

Many listings on this shelf come from makers who also publish metric figures. Where a page converts cubic meters to gallons, millimeters to inches or liters to gallons, it uses the standard factors and keeps the maker’s figure beside the conversion. Nothing is invented to fill a gap: a figure no one published is marked as not published.

When the listing contradicts itself

Listings are written by sellers and change without notice under the same ASIN. When a title and its bullets disagree, the page says which figure it used and why. On this site that covers a Bestway oval listing 530 gallons, an Aquarian steel wall pool titled 24 ft, a Hayward XStream listed at 1.1 and 1.5 HP, and an XtremepowerUS tank sold as 175 sq ft with a 150 sq ft element.

What the commission pulls toward

Affiliate income favors expensive products. What resists it is the structure of each family page: its criteria are stated before the products, and a cheaper product that meets them is ranked accordingly. A $74 Intex 1,000 GPH cartridge pump is the right answer for a small frame pool, and the page says so.

One bias remains. The site covers what Amazon.com sells. Equipment sold only by pool stores or direct from the maker is missing, and where that matters, as with in-ground heaters, the page says so.

Two things this site will not say

No page says a product makes a pool safe. Pages report what the maker states: the load a ladder is rated for, the IP rating of a light, the circuit a heater needs. Safety depends on installation, supervision and local codes, which no listing knows. Pool wiring in the US follows NEC Article 680 and is a job for a licensed electrician.

No page says what your water needs. A label dose per 10,000 gallons is a property of a product. What a pool needs on a given day depends on sunlight, bathers, rain and what a test shows, and the manufacturer’s label and safety data sheet come before anything written here.

What readers keep writing in to ask

Where does the score on each product page come from?

From Amazon.com buyer ratings, read on November 2, 2026. The average star rating is pulled toward 4.3 by the equivalent of 20 ratings, so a product with a handful of five-star reviews does not outrank one with thousands, then scaled to 10. It measures buyer satisfaction.

Where do the figures on each page come from?

From the Amazon.com listing, its bullets and table, the maker’s published documents where they exist, and the figures on rival listings. Each figure names its source, and a page says where two sources disagree.

Can a manufacturer pay for a better position?

Yes. We accept paid partnerships and paid placements from manufacturers: every paid post or placement is labeled as such on the page where it appears, and the verdict and the flaws we report stay ours. The site earns a commission on Amazon purchases through its links, at no cost to the buyer, and that commission is the same whichever product you choose.

What happens when a listing contradicts itself?

The page says so and names the figure it used. A Bestway oval listing 530 gallons, an Aquarian pool titled 24 ft with bullets for another size, and a Hayward pump listed at two horsepower ratings are all called out on their pages.

Why will this site not tell me how much chlorine my pool needs?

Because it depends on your water, sunlight, bathers and test results, which no listing knows. Pages give the dose the label states per 10,000 gallons and point you to a test kit.

Last reviewed November 2, 2026

Any amount written into the prose below was read once, the day that sentence was composed, and nothing has updated it since. The figure a shop is asking today loads next to the product itself, and that is the only live one on this page.