Skip to content

When to move a pool to sand filtration

A sand filter is backwashed instead of replaced, which turns the filter from a monthly purchase into a five-year one. The question is when the switch pays, and which filter fits your pool and hoses.

When sand pays

Cartridges are cheap one at a time; Intex says to change its Type B every 2 weeks. On a pool that stays up all summer, that adds up. Sand is backwashed, and the bed lasts years.

Intex pools

The SX1500 states 1,050 GPH in the pool for up to 8,400 gallons; the SX2800 states 2,150 GPH for up to 17,200 gallons and has about 5,400 ratings.

Other above-ground pools

The Aquastrong and Bestway include adapters for 1.25 and 1.5 in hoses; the Bestway adds a strainer basket and gauge.

A tank that outlasts the pump

The Hayward ProSeries 18 in has 1,840 ratings at 4.6. Pair it with a pump whose flow stays below the tank’s rating, and stop the pump before turning the valve.

The picks, and why they sit in this order

  1. Intex Krystal Clear SX2800

    2,800 GPH at the pump, 2,150 GPH in the pool · 14 in tank · pools 5,500-17,200 gal · 6-function valve · 24 h timer

    The bigger Intex sand filter: a 14 in tank for pools of 5,500 to 17,200 gallons, with 2,800 GPH at the pump and 2,150 GPH in the pool. About 5,400 ratings at 4.4.

    Best for: An 18 to 24 ft frame pool, or an Intex Ultra XTR owner replacing the original filter.

    8.0/10

    ≈ $223

  2. AQUASTRONG 12 in Sand Filter, 1/2 HP

    12 in tank, 50 lb sand · 1/2 HP, 2,500 GPH (2,000 system) · 6-way valve · 9-step timer 2-24 h · 2-year warranty

    A 12 in sand filter with a 1/2 HP pump that states its system flow, 2,000 GPH against 2,500 at the pump, and ships with adapters for Intex and Bestway pools.

    Best for: A 12 to 15 ft frame pool owner who wants a sand filter that fits any brand.

    7.8/10

    ≈ $180

  3. Bestway Flowclear 2,200 GPH Sand

    2,200 GPH · pools 300-14,400 gal · 6-position valve · strainer basket · 44.1 lb #20 sand or 1.23 lb Polysphere

    Bestway’s sand filter pump with a prefilter strainer basket, a pressure gauge and adapters for most above-ground pools. It takes 44.1 lb of #20 silica sand or 1.23 lb of filter balls.

    Best for: An above-ground pool owner on non-Intex fittings who wants a gauge and a strainer basket.

    7.8/10

    ≈ $220

Questions that follow from this

How long does filter sand last?

Intex says up to 5 years with regular backwashing.

Where does backwash water go?

Out of the pool, hundreds of gallons at a time. Check where your town allows it to drain.

Sand or filter balls?

Bestway allows either: 44.1 lb of #20 sand or 1.23 lb of Polysphere balls.

Each unit, and the pool it was sized for

What each band of spending keeps clear

In brief here here

Comparisons that are useful here

Unit against unit, where that comparison is already published here.

How this ranking was produced

The units above come from the catalog of this site. Specifications are those the Amazon.com listing and the maker publish; prices are what Amazon.com showed on the day each listing was read, and both move. The order uses declared specifications, stated strengths set against stated limits, and price. Nothing here has been run on a pool by us, and no page claims it has.

Last checked on

Any amount written into the prose below was read once, the day that sentence was composed, and nothing has updated it since. The figure a shop is asking today loads next to the product itself, and that is the only live one on this page.