Skip to content

Closing a pool for winter, and what to buy for it

Winter damage comes from water that freezes where it should not: in the pump, the filter, the valve and on top of the cover. Closing a pool is mostly about getting that water out and keeping it out.

Balance before you close

Test with a full kit such as the Taylor K-2005: pH, alkalinity and chlorine set before closing make the spring opening easier.

Drain the equipment

Water left in a pump body or filter tank cracks it in a freeze. Use the drain plugs; sand filters such as the Hayward ProSeries have a large drain for this.

Keep the cover clear

The Little Giant APCP-1700 starts at 2 in of water and stops at 1 in. In hard winters, the WAYNE WAPC250 adds freeze protection. On an above-ground pool, a Swimline siphon needs no power.

Lowering the water

A utility pump such as the Superior Pump 91250 moves up to 1,800 GPH. Check where local rules allow pool water to drain.

The picks, and why they sit in this order

  1. Little Giant APCP-1700 Cover Pump

    1/3 HP, 270 W, 2.2 A · 1,700 GPH at 1 ft · on at 2 in, off at 1 in · 1 in FNPT · 25 ft cord · 3-year warranty

    The best-known automatic cover pump in the US: Little Giant’s APCP-1700, on at 2 in of water and off at 1 in, 1,700 GPH at 1 ft of lift, with a 3-year warranty.

    Best for: An in-ground or above-ground winter cover, left alone all season.

    8.1/10

    ≈ $156

  2. WAYNE WAPC250 Cover Pump

    1/4 HP · 3,000 GPH with 1-1/4 in hose · iSwitch on at 2-1/8 in, off at 3/4 in · freeze protection · check valve · USA-assembled

    WAYNE’s cover pump with iSwitch: on at 2-1/8 in, off at 3/4 in, freeze protection, a locked-impeller circuit, a check valve and a pull-to-shore rope, assembled in the USA.

    Best for: A large winter cover in a cold climate, where ice and debris jam cheaper pumps.

    7.6/10

    ≈ $204

  3. Swimline Cover Saver Siphon

    Manual siphon, no electricity · for winter covers on above-ground pools · 3.2 lb · 1-year warranty

    The cheapest way to keep a winter cover from sagging: a manual siphon that needs no power or batteries. Swimline says it removes the water that would otherwise freeze on the cover.

    Best for: An above-ground pool owner who wants a cover drain that cannot short or burn out.

    7.8/10

    ≈ $24

  4. Taylor K-2005 DPD 9-in-1

    13 reagents · free and total chlorine, bromine, pH, acid and base demand, alkalinity, calcium hardness, cyanuric acid · USA

    A complete home test kit from the best-known US maker: Taylor’s K-2005, with 13 reagents for nine tests including calcium hardness and cyanuric acid. About 3,670 ratings at 4.6.

    Best for: Any owner who wants to balance water properly and stop guessing.

    8.3/10

    ≈ $74

  5. Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP Utility Pump

    1/4 HP · 1,800 GPH · 25 ft lift · 1-1/4 in NPT discharge, 3/4 in hose adapter · 1/8 in solids · 10 ft cord

    A 1/4 HP thermoplastic utility pump moving up to 1,800 GPH with 25 ft of lift, used for draining pools, spas and flooded basements. About 26,000 ratings at 4.6.

    Best for: Draining a pool, spa or cover at the start or end of the season.

    8.3/10

    ≈ $60

Questions that follow from this

Should I drain an above-ground pool?

Follow the maker. Many frame pools are taken down; steel wall pools stay up with the water partly lowered.

Why remove water from the cover?

Standing water stretches the cover and can freeze. An automatic pump clears it.

Do I need a special pump?

Little Giant, WAYNE and SEESII sell automatic cover pumps; a siphon works if there is a lower point to drain to.

Each unit, and the pool it was sized for

What each band of spending keeps clear

In brief here here

How this ranking was produced

The units above come from the catalog of this site. Specifications are those the Amazon.com listing and the maker publish; prices are what Amazon.com showed on the day each listing was read, and both move. The order uses declared specifications, stated strengths set against stated limits, and price. Nothing here has been run on a pool by us, and no page claims it has.

Last checked on

Any amount written into the prose below was read once, the day that sentence was composed, and nothing has updated it since. The figure a shop is asking today loads next to the product itself, and that is the only live one on this page.