Skip to content

Aquarian Phoenix 18 ft x 52 in vs Bestway Hydrium 18 ft x 52 in

Which 18 ft steel wall pool costs less once it can hold water?

Both are 18 ft round, 52 in deep, galvanized steel. The Aquarian is cheaper and sold as the structure; the Bestway costs more and arrives complete.

Aquarian Phoenix 18 ft x 52 in

Aquarian Phoenix 18 ft x 52 in

7.2/10

Wins 2 of 7

Check price

≈ $1,250

Bestway Hydrium 18 ft x 52 in

Bestway Hydrium 18 ft x 52 in

7.4/10

Wins 3 of 7

Check price

≈ $1,675

Rate against rate

Compared on Phoenix 18 ft x 52 in Hydrium 18 ft x 52 in
Size 18 ft x 52 in 18 ft x 52 in
Stated capacity 6,750 gallons 7,192 gallons at 90%
Liner Sold separately Included
Filter Not included 1,600-gallon sand filter pump
Skimmer and ladder Sold separately Included
Frame 6 in steel top rails, 5 in pillars Galvanized steel ridge wall
Price read About $1,250 About $1,675
Listed on amazon.com Yes Yes

A tick means one listing published something the other did not, or published a better figure. It does not mean the product is better, and the column is not a score out of anything: a maker who says less loses lines here without losing a comparison. The two verdicts below are where the page is settled.

Which of the two, for which pool

Buy the Aquarian Phoenix 18 ft x 52 in

Buy the Aquarian if you want to choose your own liner and filter, or already own them. The structure is cheaper and its top rails are wide.

Buy the Bestway Hydrium 18 ft x 52 in

Buy the Bestway if you want one box. Counted with a liner, filter, skimmer and ladder, it is the cheaper pool.

The questions these two raise

What does the Aquarian need?

A liner, a skimmer, a filter with pump and a ladder, per its listing.

Is the Bestway pump big enough?

It is the same pump as on the 15 ft Hydrium. Plan for long run times on 7,192 gallons.

The full detail on each

Any amount written into the prose below was read once, the day that sentence was composed, and nothing has updated it since. The figure a shop is asking today loads next to the product itself, and that is the only live one on this page.